The Berlin-Brandenburg Regional Labor Court has, by judgment of 03.06.2010, decided that a pre-formulated clause in an employment contract, according to which the gross remuneration to be paid is deemed to compensate overtime or extra work, violates the transparency requirement of § 307 Abs. 1 Satz 2 BGB, places the employee at an undue disadvantage and therefore is unenforceable.
According to the court's view, which in this context aligns with the jurisprudence of the Federal Labor Court, it is fundamentally the employer's task to make such contractual clauses more transparent.
The employer is therefore required to specify concretely the portion of the monthly earnings with which he intends to compensate the corresponding overtime or extra work on a flat-rate basis.
A claim for overtime pay furthermore requires, according to the BAG's longstanding case law, that the overtime was ordered by the employer, approved or tolerated, or at least necessary to perform the owed work.
The Berlin-Brandenburg Regional Labor Court, in its present judgment, assumes that an employer tolerates overtime as soon as he accepts work performances that go beyond the regular working time, provided that the provision of overtime occurs over several weeks and the employer makes no serious organizational arrangements to prevent voluntary overtime.
This view that merely accepting voluntary overtime by the employee while refraining from countermeasures constitutes toleration of overtime is very far-reaching. It will have to become evident to what extent this view also prevails in other state labor courts.
Through the decision of the Berlin-Brandenburg LAG, in any event, another path to grounding a claim for the payment of overtime has been opened.
vgl. LAG Berlin-Brandenburg, Urteil vom 03.06.2010, Az. 15 Sa 166/10
Attorney Sven Siegrist, Schwetzingen
Lawyers Zipper & Collegen, Schwetzingen
http://www.arbeitsrecht-anwalt.info